Emilio Botin, former president of the Spanish bank Banco Santander, giving a press conference to announce the 2011 annual results in Madrid and (Right) Ana Patricia Botin, daughter of late Emilio Botin. Spanish media report after the death of her father, Patricia Botin could be appointed as the new chairman to replace her father who was in charge of the bank for 28 years.
Reuters
|
|
Emilio Botin, one of Spain’s most powerful men who transformed Santander from a small domestic lender into the eurozone’s biggest bank, has died of a heart attack, aged 79.
Sources familiar with the matter said his eldest daughter Ana Botin, currently head of Santander’s British business, was expected to be approved as the bank’s new chairman at a board meeting.
Such a move could spark controversy, with banking dynasties coming under criticism after a scandal at Portugal’s Banco Espirito Santo, where the founding family’s holdings are being investigated over financial irregularities.
“Succession shouldn’t just be saying ‘my daughter’s going to take over’,” said a corporate governance expert at a global asset manager which owns Santander shares, speaking on condition of anonymity.
But others said Ana Botin, who has spent most of the last 25 years at Santander, could provide welcome continuity.
“The key issue is whether or not family control is a good or a bad thing. Ultimately this depends on individuals and his (Botin’s) daughter is a chip off the old block,” said Philip Saunders, co-head of multi-asset at Investec Asset Management.
“More often than not, family control or strong influence tends to bolster long termism which is particularly important in a banking context given that banks typically behave in an overly pro cyclical manner and destroy shareholder value as a consequence,” he said.
If Ana Botin is confirmed as group chairman, it will leave a gap at Santander’s UK arm just as it prepares for a separate listing. UK Finance Director Nathan Bostock has been lined up as her replacement, but he only joined a month ago. The UK arm is also looking for a new chairman.
Emilio Botin, “El Presidente” to co-workers and the third generation of Botins to run Santander, was at the forefront of a drive to create global banks, offering a one-stop shop to multinational companies and a range of services to consumers.
He used a keen eye for deals to spread Santander’s red-liveried brand with its stylised ‘S’ logo around the world, amassing €1.4tn ($1.8tn) of funds and nearly 200,000 employees.
“He was a man who has been able to make Banco Santander the most important bank of our country,” Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy told journalists in Parliament.
“I had a meeting with him last week and he was well and in good form. It has been a surprise and a blow.”
Botin shook up Spanish banking with a campaign to attract depositors in 1989, forcing rivals to compete on price, and bought troubled Banesto in 1994 to create Spain’s biggest bank.
He took advantage of cultural and language ties to expand rapidly into Latin America, and in 2004 snapped up Britain’s Abbey National for more than £9bn ($14.5bn).
More canny deal-making followed. In 2007, Santander made €2.4bn in three weeks through deals to buy and then sell Italian bank Antonveneta. And while partners RBS and Fortis were driven to seek state bailouts after a carve up of ABN Amro on the eve of the financial crisis, Santander emerged comparatively unscathed with the Dutch group’s healthier Brazilian arm.
The expansion helped to shield Santander from the eurozone debt crisis and Spain’s long-running recession, with the bank now making only about 14% of its profit at home.
But it has not been all success. Santander has trailed the total returns to shareholders delivered in the past 10 years by rivals JPMorgan and HSBC — two firms Botin liked to measures himself against, according to colleagues.
There has been controversy too. Botin’s family, which owns barely 2% of Santander, paid €200mn in penalties in 2011 to avoid charges of tax evasion related to a secret Swiss bank account.
Few doubt Ana Botin, 53, has a strong claim to succeed her father. But her high profile in the bank has drawn criticism.
Earlier this year two shareholder advisory firms, ISS and Glass Lewis & Co, recommended shareholders vote against her re-election as a director — one because it thought Botins were over-represented on the board, the other because it considered there were not enough independent members.
In the event, she got the backing of 81.3% of the votes, almost unchanged from three years earlier.
“Botin was the unofficial king of Spain. His death creates uncertainty and a power vacuum at the top,” said a London-based hedge fund manager, who declined to be named.
“The obvious successor is his daughter Ana, which was always the plan, but he hasn’t had a proper chance to groom her and install her as chairwoman before he died so there could be some infighting.”